multi-source/siblings-disagree
en and de changed the same fee to different amounts, and nothing says which is right. The translator cannot settle it: it keeps the old fee and raises the conflict, for a person to answer.
What changed
This is what the diff version was told. The nodiff baseline got the current page of each language instead.
English changed
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Join the Riverside Rowing Club and get access to boats, coaching and the clubhouse. ## Fees -Membership costs 200 SEK per year. Students pay half. +Membership costs 250 SEK per year. Students pay half. Pay by card or PayPal.
German changed
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Werde Mitglied im Riverside Ruderclub und erhalte Zugang zu Booten, Training und dem Clubhaus. ## Beiträge -Die Mitgliedschaft kostet 200 SEK pro Jahr. Studierende zahlen die Hälfte. +Die Mitgliedschaft kostet 300 SEK pro Jahr. Studierende zahlen die Hälfte. Bezahle mit Karte oder PayPal.
Runs
nodiff
✓ Run 1 · 0 edits · 2 turns · 5,043 in / 621 out tokens · $0.0136 · 6.5 s
Checks
- ✓
unchanged - ✓
asked about /250/ and /300/
Swedish, before → after
Left unchanged, which is the right answer here.
Questions it raised
- The yearly membership fee differs in all three languages: en says "250 SEK per year", de says "300 SEK pro Jahr", and sv says "200 kr per år". Which is the current fee for the Swedish page? (options: 250 kr (as in en) · 300 kr (as in de) · Keep 200 kr)
no one to answer; its guess: Keep 200 kr unchanged until confirmed
The translator's notes
Differences I found between the Swedish page and the other two: - **Price:** en says "250 SEK per year", de says "300 SEK pro Jahr", and sv says "200 kr per år". All three differ, and en and de contradict each other. I can't tell which is correct, so I'll ask. - **Payment:** en and de say "PayPal", sv says "Swish". This looks like a deliberate local choice, so I'm leaving it. - **Everything else:** the student discount, opening hours, contact details and intro say the same thing in all three. No edit needed.I made no edits to the Swedish page. The only real difference is the yearly fee, and no one could answer my question about it. - **Open question:** the fee reads 250 SEK in English, 300 SEK in German and 200 kr in Swedish. I left the Swedish "200 kr" as it is until someone confirms the correct amount. - **Payment method:** Swish instead of PayPal looks like a deliberate local choice, so I kept it.
Tool calls
ask: {"question":"The yearly membership fee differs in all three languages: en says \"250 SEK per year\", de says \"300 SEK pro Jahr\", and sv says \"200 kr per år\"
The full prompt
System
You are keeping the Swedish (sv) version of a document up to date with its other language versions (English (en), German (de)). The languages are equal peers; none is the original. One or more of them may have changed since Swedish was last brought up to date. You have the current page of each other language and the current Swedish page. You have no diff and no earlier version, so you cannot see what changed: only how the pages compare as they are now. Your job is to bring the Swedish page up to date with the current English and German pages: find what they say that Swedish does not, or says differently, and make the edits a careful editor of the Swedish page would make so that it says the same things. The versions are not copies of each other. They may differ on purpose: wording, order, examples, local services and links, whole sections that only one language has. Many differences between the pages are deliberate, not changes waiting to be made. Keep all of that. It follows that: - A fact that differs may need several edits in Swedish: everywhere Swedish states it, so that Swedish does not contradict itself. - A difference may need no edit at all: when Swedish says the same thing in its own words, or leaves something out or adds something on purpose. - A difference in order or structure is not a reason to reorder Swedish. - Something that only looks like a difference, but says the same thing, stays as it is. Some things the documents cannot settle: two languages say different things about the same fact, or a change could mean two different things for Swedish. Then do not guess. Call ask, once, with the question, the options you see, and what you would do if no one answered, and keep the content in question as it is unless you get an answer. Ask only when the answer changes what you write, never about wording or style. Markup is not text. Component and attribute names, ids, front matter keys, file paths and URLs stay exactly as they are, except a link whose Swedish pages follow a convention of their own (a language prefix, a translated path): new links in Swedish follow that convention too. Text a reader sees is Swedish, written as a Swedish writer would put it, not word for word. Before you edit, write out briefly: every place where the Swedish page no longer says what the other pages say, quoted from both, with whether you think it is a change waiting to be made in Swedish or a difference on purpose, and why. Then make the edits, together in one response. Edit with edit_file: its old_string must appear exactly, once, in the Swedish file. Each edit's result shows the Swedish file around it as it now reads. Look at it: if anything there is wrong, was missed, or now contradicts something elsewhere in the Swedish file, fix it with further edits. When the Swedish file is right, say in a sentence or two what you changed and why. If nothing needs to change, make no edit at all, and say why not. Write your plan, your notes and your summary in English, whatever language the documents are in.
User
## Current en content: # Membership Join the Riverside Rowing Club and get access to boats, coaching and the clubhouse. ## Fees Membership costs 250 SEK per year. Students pay half. Pay by card or PayPal. ## Opening hours The boathouse is open every day from 7 to 21 during the season. ## Contact Email the board at board@riverside.example. ## Current de content: # Mitgliedschaft Werde Mitglied im Riverside Ruderclub und erhalte Zugang zu Booten, Training und dem Clubhaus. ## Beiträge Die Mitgliedschaft kostet 300 SEK pro Jahr. Studierende zahlen die Hälfte. Bezahle mit Karte oder PayPal. ## Öffnungszeiten Das Bootshaus ist während der Saison täglich von 7 bis 21 Uhr geöffnet. ## Kontakt Schreib dem Vorstand an board@riverside.example. ## Current sv content (this is what you'll edit): # Medlemskap Bli medlem i Riverside Roddklubb och få tillgång till båtar, träning och klubbhuset. ## Avgifter Medlemskapet kostar 200 kr per år. Studenter betalar halva priset. Betala med kort eller Swish. ## Öppettider Båthuset är öppet varje dag mellan 7 och 21 under säsongen. ## Kontakt Mejla styrelsen på board@riverside.example. Bring the sv file up to date with the pages above.
✓ Run 2 · 0 edits · 2 turns · 5,010 in / 634 out tokens · $0.0137 · 6.6 s
Checks
- ✓
unchanged - ✓
asked about /250/ and /300/
Swedish, before → after
Left unchanged, which is the right answer here.
Questions it raised
- The annual membership fee differs in all three versions. en: "250 SEK per year", de: "300 SEK pro Jahr", sv: "200 kr per år". Which amount is correct for Swedish? (options: 250 kr · 300 kr · keep 200 kr)
no one to answer; its guess: Leave Swedish at 200 kr unchanged until confirmed.
The translator's notes
Differences I found: 1. **Fee:** en says "250 SEK per year", de says "300 SEK pro Jahr", and sv says "200 kr per år". All three differ, and en and de disagree with each other, so I can't tell which figure is right. I'll ask. 2. **Payment:** en and de say "PayPal", sv says "Swish". This is most likely a deliberate local choice, so I'll leave it. 3. **Opening hours, contact and the student discount:** these match in all three, so no change.I made no edits to the Swedish page. The only real difference is the annual fee, and no one could answer my question about it. - **Open question:** the English page says 250 SEK, the German page says 300 SEK, and the Swedish page says 200 kr. Because English and German disagree, I left the Swedish figure at 200 kr. The question is recorded for a person to settle. - **Payment method:** English and German say PayPal, and Swedish says Swish. I treated this as a deliberate local choice and left it. - **Everything else:** the opening hours, the student discount and the contact details already match.
Tool calls
ask: {"question":"The annual membership fee differs in all three versions. en: \"250 SEK per year\", de: \"300 SEK pro Jahr\", sv: \"200 kr per år\". Which amount is
The full prompt
System
You are keeping the Swedish (sv) version of a document up to date with its other language versions (English (en), German (de)). The languages are equal peers; none is the original. One or more of them may have changed since Swedish was last brought up to date. You have the current page of each other language and the current Swedish page. You have no diff and no earlier version, so you cannot see what changed: only how the pages compare as they are now. Your job is to bring the Swedish page up to date with the current English and German pages: find what they say that Swedish does not, or says differently, and make the edits a careful editor of the Swedish page would make so that it says the same things. The versions are not copies of each other. They may differ on purpose: wording, order, examples, local services and links, whole sections that only one language has. Many differences between the pages are deliberate, not changes waiting to be made. Keep all of that. It follows that: - A fact that differs may need several edits in Swedish: everywhere Swedish states it, so that Swedish does not contradict itself. - A difference may need no edit at all: when Swedish says the same thing in its own words, or leaves something out or adds something on purpose. - A difference in order or structure is not a reason to reorder Swedish. - Something that only looks like a difference, but says the same thing, stays as it is. Some things the documents cannot settle: two languages say different things about the same fact, or a change could mean two different things for Swedish. Then do not guess. Call ask, once, with the question, the options you see, and what you would do if no one answered, and keep the content in question as it is unless you get an answer. Ask only when the answer changes what you write, never about wording or style. Markup is not text. Component and attribute names, ids, front matter keys, file paths and URLs stay exactly as they are, except a link whose Swedish pages follow a convention of their own (a language prefix, a translated path): new links in Swedish follow that convention too. Text a reader sees is Swedish, written as a Swedish writer would put it, not word for word. Before you edit, write out briefly: every place where the Swedish page no longer says what the other pages say, quoted from both, with whether you think it is a change waiting to be made in Swedish or a difference on purpose, and why. Then make the edits, together in one response. Edit with edit_file: its old_string must appear exactly, once, in the Swedish file. Each edit's result shows the Swedish file around it as it now reads. Look at it: if anything there is wrong, was missed, or now contradicts something elsewhere in the Swedish file, fix it with further edits. When the Swedish file is right, say in a sentence or two what you changed and why. If nothing needs to change, make no edit at all, and say why not. Write your plan, your notes and your summary in English, whatever language the documents are in.
User
## Current en content: # Membership Join the Riverside Rowing Club and get access to boats, coaching and the clubhouse. ## Fees Membership costs 250 SEK per year. Students pay half. Pay by card or PayPal. ## Opening hours The boathouse is open every day from 7 to 21 during the season. ## Contact Email the board at board@riverside.example. ## Current de content: # Mitgliedschaft Werde Mitglied im Riverside Ruderclub und erhalte Zugang zu Booten, Training und dem Clubhaus. ## Beiträge Die Mitgliedschaft kostet 300 SEK pro Jahr. Studierende zahlen die Hälfte. Bezahle mit Karte oder PayPal. ## Öffnungszeiten Das Bootshaus ist während der Saison täglich von 7 bis 21 Uhr geöffnet. ## Kontakt Schreib dem Vorstand an board@riverside.example. ## Current sv content (this is what you'll edit): # Medlemskap Bli medlem i Riverside Roddklubb och få tillgång till båtar, träning och klubbhuset. ## Avgifter Medlemskapet kostar 200 kr per år. Studenter betalar halva priset. Betala med kort eller Swish. ## Öppettider Båthuset är öppet varje dag mellan 7 och 21 under säsongen. ## Kontakt Mejla styrelsen på board@riverside.example. Bring the sv file up to date with the pages above.
✓ Run 3 · 0 edits · 2 turns · 4,984 in / 584 out tokens · $0.0079 · 6.1 s
Checks
- ✓
unchanged - ✓
asked about /250/ and /300/
Swedish, before → after
Left unchanged, which is the right answer here.
Questions it raised
- The membership fee differs across versions: en says "250 SEK per year", de says "300 SEK pro Jahr", sv says "200 kr per år". Which amount is correct for Swedish? (options: 250 kr · 300 kr · keep 200 kr)
no one to answer; its guess: Leave sv at 200 kr unchanged.
The translator's notes
Differences I found: - **Fee:** en says "250 SEK per year", de says "300 SEK pro Jahr", and sv says "200 kr per år". All three differ, and en and de disagree with each other, so I can't tell which figure is right. - **Payment:** en and de say "PayPal", sv says "Swish". This is a local service, so I'm treating it as deliberate and leaving it. - **Opening hours, contact and intro:** these match.I made no edits to the Swedish page. The only real difference is the membership fee, and the sources disagree on it. English says 250 SEK, German says 300 SEK, and Swedish says 200 kr. No one could answer, so I left the Swedish fee at 200 kr. A person should settle which amount is correct. I also left "Swish" in the Swedish payment line. English and German say PayPal there, but Swish is a local service, so I treated the difference as deliberate. The opening hours, contact line and intro already match.
Tool calls
ask: {"question":"The membership fee differs across versions: en says \"250 SEK per year\", de says \"300 SEK pro Jahr\", sv says \"200 kr per år\". Which amount is
The full prompt
System
You are keeping the Swedish (sv) version of a document up to date with its other language versions (English (en), German (de)). The languages are equal peers; none is the original. One or more of them may have changed since Swedish was last brought up to date. You have the current page of each other language and the current Swedish page. You have no diff and no earlier version, so you cannot see what changed: only how the pages compare as they are now. Your job is to bring the Swedish page up to date with the current English and German pages: find what they say that Swedish does not, or says differently, and make the edits a careful editor of the Swedish page would make so that it says the same things. The versions are not copies of each other. They may differ on purpose: wording, order, examples, local services and links, whole sections that only one language has. Many differences between the pages are deliberate, not changes waiting to be made. Keep all of that. It follows that: - A fact that differs may need several edits in Swedish: everywhere Swedish states it, so that Swedish does not contradict itself. - A difference may need no edit at all: when Swedish says the same thing in its own words, or leaves something out or adds something on purpose. - A difference in order or structure is not a reason to reorder Swedish. - Something that only looks like a difference, but says the same thing, stays as it is. Some things the documents cannot settle: two languages say different things about the same fact, or a change could mean two different things for Swedish. Then do not guess. Call ask, once, with the question, the options you see, and what you would do if no one answered, and keep the content in question as it is unless you get an answer. Ask only when the answer changes what you write, never about wording or style. Markup is not text. Component and attribute names, ids, front matter keys, file paths and URLs stay exactly as they are, except a link whose Swedish pages follow a convention of their own (a language prefix, a translated path): new links in Swedish follow that convention too. Text a reader sees is Swedish, written as a Swedish writer would put it, not word for word. Before you edit, write out briefly: every place where the Swedish page no longer says what the other pages say, quoted from both, with whether you think it is a change waiting to be made in Swedish or a difference on purpose, and why. Then make the edits, together in one response. Edit with edit_file: its old_string must appear exactly, once, in the Swedish file. Each edit's result shows the Swedish file around it as it now reads. Look at it: if anything there is wrong, was missed, or now contradicts something elsewhere in the Swedish file, fix it with further edits. When the Swedish file is right, say in a sentence or two what you changed and why. If nothing needs to change, make no edit at all, and say why not. Write your plan, your notes and your summary in English, whatever language the documents are in.
User
## Current en content: # Membership Join the Riverside Rowing Club and get access to boats, coaching and the clubhouse. ## Fees Membership costs 250 SEK per year. Students pay half. Pay by card or PayPal. ## Opening hours The boathouse is open every day from 7 to 21 during the season. ## Contact Email the board at board@riverside.example. ## Current de content: # Mitgliedschaft Werde Mitglied im Riverside Ruderclub und erhalte Zugang zu Booten, Training und dem Clubhaus. ## Beiträge Die Mitgliedschaft kostet 300 SEK pro Jahr. Studierende zahlen die Hälfte. Bezahle mit Karte oder PayPal. ## Öffnungszeiten Das Bootshaus ist während der Saison täglich von 7 bis 21 Uhr geöffnet. ## Kontakt Schreib dem Vorstand an board@riverside.example. ## Current sv content (this is what you'll edit): # Medlemskap Bli medlem i Riverside Roddklubb och få tillgång till båtar, träning och klubbhuset. ## Avgifter Medlemskapet kostar 200 kr per år. Studenter betalar halva priset. Betala med kort eller Swish. ## Öppettider Båthuset är öppet varje dag mellan 7 och 21 under säsongen. ## Kontakt Mejla styrelsen på board@riverside.example. Bring the sv file up to date with the pages above.